本文已被:浏览 369次 下载 292次
投稿时间:2024-01-03 修订日期:2024-01-22
投稿时间:2024-01-03 修订日期:2024-01-22
中文摘要: 目前,酸中性土壤交换性盐基总量的检测方法为乙酸铵交换-中和滴定法,其特点为步骤繁杂、操作难度大,也是全国三普内业指标实验中的技术难点之一。通过采用多类土壤标准物质为研究对象,探讨样品质量、交换试剂、检测方式对盐基总量的影响,并对土壤交换性盐基总量与交换性盐基各离子之间的相关性进行了分析。结果表明, 高含量盐基样品ASA-7a在添加与不添加EDTA的乙酸铵溶液交换下ICP-OES加和盐基总量值分别为34.71±0.10 cmol?kg-1、33.26±0.18 cmol?kg-1,中和滴定检测后一交换液的值则偏高,达到38.80±0.62 cmol?kg-1,并且不同交换试剂间和检测方式间均有一定差异性(P<0.05)。但样品质量的多少对盐基总量的结果无显著影响(P>0.05)。尽管ICP-OES加和的盐基总量的相对误差RE与相对标准偏差RSD分别小于7%、1.2%,其精密度与准确度均优于中和滴定法,但两种检测方式结果均在标准参考值范围内。对于批量样品土壤交换性盐基总量的测定与数据的比对统计分析,建议遵照统一的规程并保持方法的一致性,避免因方法的不同而增大结果的差异性。
Abstract:At present, the detection method of total exchangeable base in acid-neutral soil is ammonium acetate exchange-neutralization titration. This method is detailed and complicated and is difficult to operate, which is one of the technological difficulties in the internal industry index of third national soil survey. In this paper, the standard reference material of soils were used as the research objects to research the effect of quality of samples, exchange reagents and detection method on total soil exchangeable base, and the total soil exchangeable base and their correlation with exchangeable base cations were analyzed. The results showed that the total exchangeable base by ICP addition of ASA-7a, a high-content exchangeable-based standard sample, was 34.71±0.10 cmol?kg-1 and 33.26±0.18 cmol?kg-1 under the exchange of ammonium acetate solution with and without EDTA, respectively. The total exchangeable base of ASA-7a was slightly higher detected by neutralization titration under the exchange of ammonium acetate solution without EDTA, which reached 38.80±0.62 cmol?kg-1. Different exchange reagents and detection methods had certain differences(P<0.05). But the quality of samples had no significant effect on the determination of the total exchangeable base (P<0.05). Although the relative error and relative standard deviation of the total exchangeable base by the ICP-OES addition were less than 7% and 1.2%, respectively, indicating that the precision and accuracy of the two methods were better than those of the neutralization titration method, the results of the two methods were within the standard reference value. For the determination of total soil exchangeable base and the statistical analysis of data of batch samples, it is recommended to follow the consistent protocol and maintain the consistency of the method to avoid increasing the difference of results due to the difference of the methods.
keywords: Acid-neutral soil total exchangeable base ammonium acetate neutralization titration ICP-OES
文章编号: 中图分类号:O611 O655.22 文献标志码:
基金项目:国家重点研发资助项目(2020YFC1807200)
引用文本:
陆文苑,蒋倩,唐昊冶,刘云,王雪娇,孙晓丽,王彦,朱波,陆国兴,陈虹.酸中性土壤交换性盐基总量检测方法的影响因素[J].中国无机分析化学,2024,14(11):1554-1562.
LU Wenyuan,JIANG Qian,TANG Haoye,LIU Yun,WANG Xuejiao,SUN Xiaoli,WANG Yan,ZHU Bo,LU Guoxing,CHEN Hong.Factors on the Detection Methods of Total Exchangeable Base in Acidic and Neutral Soils[J].Chinese Journal of Inorganic Analytical Chemistry,2024,14(11):1554-1562.
陆文苑,蒋倩,唐昊冶,刘云,王雪娇,孙晓丽,王彦,朱波,陆国兴,陈虹.酸中性土壤交换性盐基总量检测方法的影响因素[J].中国无机分析化学,2024,14(11):1554-1562.
LU Wenyuan,JIANG Qian,TANG Haoye,LIU Yun,WANG Xuejiao,SUN Xiaoli,WANG Yan,ZHU Bo,LU Guoxing,CHEN Hong.Factors on the Detection Methods of Total Exchangeable Base in Acidic and Neutral Soils[J].Chinese Journal of Inorganic Analytical Chemistry,2024,14(11):1554-1562.